I had the good fortune to be her student at Sapienza, and to value her, even before I knew her as the author of the column “The Right to Beauty,” for the depth of her teaching and the humanity that accompanied it. It was this union of scholarly rigor and personal generosity that convinced me that asking her to write a column in these pages would not be a simple editorial act, but a way of giving back to readers the experience that had been mine.
Carlotta Melegari
Law as Art
“Law is art, the highest art that humankind has been able to create: because it is the art of living together.” The sentence is Francesco Carnelutti’s, and it was formulated in his Arte del diritto (The Art of Law) of 1949. In it one recognizes the intellectual program that runs through the work of Professor Giovanna Montella: to think of the legal rule not as a machine of sanctions and prohibitions but as the form in which a community decides what to keep safe—the landscape, the dignity of the home, the quality of our surroundings, the coexistence of the generations—and what, conversely, to recognize as irreparably lost if the care of the law should fail.
The Training of a Constitutional Scholar in the Roman School
Giovanna Montella was trained within the great Roman school of public law, and her training opened early to dialogue with Europe. In 1984, in Turin, she attended the Advanced Program in Transnational Training (PAFT) at the University Institute of European Studies. The following year, and again in 1987, she received two scholarships from the Italian Institute for Philosophical Studies in Naples, which enabled her to attend the courses of Professor Robert Shackleton of the University of Oxford and of Professor Bruno Neveu of the University of Paris, two masters of European legal and philosophical culture on whose teaching Montella built her comparative method. From 1985 she worked at Sapienza as a subject expert (cultore della materia), under the guidance of Professors Carlo Roehrssen (comparative constitutional law) and Giovanni Motzo (public law). In 1986 she organized at the Faculty of Law, under the High Patronage of the President of the Republic, the scholarly conference “La concezione giuridica di Carl Schmitt” (Carl Schmitt’s Conception of Law). In 1990 she joined the staff of Sapienza as a technical-scientific officer at the Institute of Public Law; in 1993, within the Jean Monnet project directed by Sabino Cassese, she gave a lecture on the organization of the Commission of the European Communities. Since March 1, 2002, she has been a tenured researcher in comparative public law at the Faculty of Law of Sapienza University of Rome, a position she holds to this day.
Teaching and Education
For four decades Montella’s teaching has ranged across the chairs of general public law, comparative public law, constitutional law, institutions of public law, cultural heritage legislation, and technical and scientific legal translation, in the Faculties of Law and of Letters at Sapienza. Of particular note is her course in constitutional law in the degree program in Law and Economics of Real Estate, a significant point of contact between the teaching of constitutional law and the concerns of those who work with homes and with the land.
Montella’s teaching, however, does not end in the university classroom. She holds seminars and talks in schools of every level, with the aim of educating young people in respect for the Italian Constitution and for public institutions; she leads courses and lectures for the training and professional development of public officials, on the liability of the public administration, equal opportunity, and workplace bullying; and she takes part regularly in the conferences and seminars of the Ordine degli Avvocati di Roma (the Rome Bar Association). Internationally, she was a member of the teaching and scientific committee of the advanced training course (CAF) “Support for the Process of Democratic Transition in Tunisia,” and chaired in Tunis, at the Chambre des Conseillers, the final evaluation committee.
Research: Constitution, Landscape, Environment, City
Over the years Montella’s scholarly work has passed through some of the decisive junctures of contemporary public law. Costantino Mortati is the intellectual point of reference to whom she returns most often: to him she devoted the paper “Il rapporto tra popolo e potere in Costantino Mortati” (The Relationship Between People and Power in Costantino Mortati), given at the 1996 National Conference in Castrovillari, and the essay “Sul rapporto tra Popolo e Potere in Costantino Mortati” (On the Relationship Between People and Power in Costantino Mortati), which appeared in 2005 in Studi in onore di Gianni Ferrara (Studies in Honor of Gianni Ferrara), through to the recent 2024 colloquium at the University of Macerata devoted to the master’s Macerata period.
She has taken part in numerous research groups, both PRIN (Research Projects of National Interest) and university-funded, coordinated by Professor Giuseppe Morbidelli, working on the judicial protection of rights in the Community legal order, banking foundations, independent administrative authorities, the constitutional dynamics of the European Convention, levels of government, and multicultural integration. Particularly significant, in view of her collaboration with LoveImmobiliare, are the two programs on renewable energy sources (PRIN 2009; the 2008 Ateneo Federato research project on the regulation of the electricity and gas sectors), which gave Montella the tools for an in-depth legal analysis of the relationship between land, infrastructure, and the protection of the environment.
It is in her recent publications, however, that Montella’s thinking comes closest to the themes of the magazine. The encyclopedia entries written for Treccani online, “Paesaggio, ambiente e qualità della vita” (Landscape, Environment, and Quality of Life; 2020) and “Diritto all’istruzione: una ‘sinfonia’ costituzionale” (The Right to Education: A Constitutional “Symphony”; 2020), form the theoretical basis of the column “The Right to Beauty”; the essay “Città, ambiente e qualità della vita” (City, Environment, and Quality of Life), published by Sapienza in 2023 in the volume La città come istituzione, entro e oltre lo Stato (The City as Institution, Within and Beyond the State), is its natural continuation. Forthcoming, in the liber amicorum dedicated to Professor Michele Ainis, is an essay of hers on the meaning of the word “Republic” in the constitutional wording of Article 9, the same article that ran through her contribution to Volume 8 of LoveImmobiliare Magazine.
“The Right to Beauty”: The Lesson of the Paesaggio Integrale
The column Montella writes for LoveImmobiliare Magazine translates this school of thought for the general reader while remaining scrupulous in its scholarship. The “beauty” of law, in her words, coincides with the capacity of the legal system to guarantee balance, measure, and quality of life; and it keeps its distance from any aestheticizing or decorative view. The reform of Article 9 of the Constitution, which in 2022 placed among the fundamental principles the protection of the environment, biodiversity, and ecosystems, also in the interest of future generations, becomes the chief point of reference around which her reflections are organized, together with the Code of Cultural Heritage and Landscape (Codice dei beni culturali e del paesaggio), which translates into administrative rules the care promised by the Constitution.
A magazine concerned with homes and with the land meets, in its pages, the gaze of the constitutional scholar who teaches us to read the paesaggio integrale, the integral landscape: the one that brings together the visible and the invisible, the built and the horizon, private property and the common good. In Montella’s thinking, the right to beauty is a shared responsibility that concerns the way we build, protect, and hand on the world we inhabit.
Academic, Editorial, and Civic Service
In her service to the university, Montella has been a member of the executive committee of the Faculty of Law and of the executive committee of the Department of Legal Sciences; she has sat on Sapienza’s University Research Committee and University Teaching Committee; and she has served on selection committees for doctoral programs, research fellowships, and researcher positions at Sapienza, Roma Tre University, and the University of Macerata. She is also a member of the teaching and scientific board of the second-level university master’s program in environmental law offered by the Department of Legal Sciences of the same university.
On the editorial side, she has been a regular contributor since 1992 to the Rivista Trimestrale di Diritto Pubblico (Public Law Quarterly Review), to the journal Cooperazione Giuridica Internazionale (International Legal Cooperation), and to Dedalus; since January 1, 2000, she has been a member of the Associazione di Diritto Pubblico Comparato ed Europeo (Association of Comparative and European Public Law) and belongs to the Rome editorial staff (at the public law section of Sapienza’s Department of Legal Sciences) of the journal Diritto Pubblico Comparato ed Europeo, published by Giappichelli.
On the civic side, finally, Montella is a member of the Committee for the Implementation of the Constitution in the Province of Viterbo, has served on the committee established by the Ministry of the Interior to award the Raffaele Abate Prize, and devotes constant attention to the constitutional education of the young: a commitment that takes the form of seminars in schools, collaboration with professional orders, and the training of public officials in matters of liability, equal opportunity, and protection against workplace bullying.
Selected Publications
Among Giovanna Montella’s more than thirty scholarly publications, a few titles are of particular relevance to the themes of the magazine:
“Il significato del lemma Repubblica nella scrittura costituzionale dell’articolo 9” (The Meaning of the Word “Republic” in the Constitutional Wording of Article 9), in the liber amicorum for Professor Michele Ainis, forthcoming (2025). “Città, ambiente e qualità della vita,” in La città come istituzione, entro e oltre lo Stato, Sapienza Università Editrice, 2023. “Minori non accompagnati tra costituzione e amministrazione” (Unaccompanied Minors Between Constitution and Administration), in Il disagio giovanile oggi (Youth Distress Today), Sapienza Università Editrice, 2022. “Paesaggio, ambiente e qualità della vita,” entry in Treccani online, 2020. “Diritto all’istruzione: una ‘sinfonia’ costituzionale,” entry in Treccani online, 2020. “Il dialogo francese con l’Europa tra monarchia e Repubblica. L’École de service public di Bordeaux” (The French Dialogue with Europe Between Monarchy and Republic: The École de service public of Bordeaux), in Eurostudium³w, 2020. “Brevi notazioni intorno al rapporto tra ordinamento giuridico ed emergenza economica” (Brief Notes on the Relationship Between the Legal Order and Economic Emergency), in Crisi economico-finanziaria, legge di bilancio e fonti del diritto (Economic and Financial Crisis, Budget Law, and Sources of Law), 2019. “Solidarietà sociale e coscienza nazionale” (Social Solidarity and National Consciousness), in Costituzionalismo.it, 2016. “Gli enti locali minori e le sollecitazioni della disciplina sulla promozione dell’uso dell’energia da fonti rinnovabili” (Smaller Local Authorities and the Demands of the Rules Promoting the Use of Energy from Renewable Sources), in Verso una politica energetica integrata (Toward an Integrated Energy Policy), 2014. “Il service public come principio in Duguit e Hauriou” (Service Public as a Principle in Duguit and Hauriou), in Rivista Italiana per le Scienze Giuridiche (Italian Review of Legal Sciences), 2014. Introduzione allo studio del diritto pubblico (Introduction to the Study of Public Law), monograph, 2012. “I confini d’Irlanda: limiti e carenze del Northern Ireland (Border) Poll 1973” (The Borders of Ireland: Limits and Shortcomings of the 1973 Northern Ireland Border Poll), in Democrazia rappresentativa e referendum nel Regno Unito (Representative Democracy and Referendums in the United Kingdom), 2012. Glossaire de droit / Glossario giuridico (Legal Glossary), Casa Editrice Università La Sapienza, 2010. “Pari opportunità” (Equal Opportunity), entry in Digesto delle Discipline Pubblicistiche (Digest of Public Law), update volume, tome II, UTET, 2008. “Sul rapporto tra Popolo e Potere in Costantino Mortati,” in Studi in onore di Gianni Ferrara, 2005. “Function and Interpretation of Fundamental Rights” and “The Evolution of Fundamental Rights and Its Influence on the Drafting of Fundamental Rights Instruments,” in Fundamental Rights in Europe and North America, 2003.
